No self-esteemed person is needed by Mamata Govt.

Sanyal quits school reforms panel after ‘rift’

Somdatta Basu | TNN 18.11.11

Kolkata: Eminent educationist Sunanda Sanyal on Thursday stepped down as chairman of the syllabus committee appointed by the Mamata Banerjee government to bring reforms in school education. Sanyal said he was suffering from chikungunya and had asked to be relieved of his duties, but insiders attributed his decision to difference of opinion with committee members and some decisions taken by the government “ignoring” his advice. 
    In July, Sanyal had quit another key panel — the higher education committee — also headed by him. 
    Sanyal is known to have strongly disagreed with the government’s decision — taken at a cabinet meeting — to do away with the pass-fail system till class VIII, accepting provisions in the Right to Education Act. Sources said one of the reasons why he chose to opt out of the school committee was that he did not want to be held responsible for decisions taken by the government. 
    The 19-member committee comprising educationists, experts and government officials submitted a draft report to education minister Bratya Basu last Monday that endorsed the government’s decision to abolish the pass-fail system. Sanyal did not attend Monday’s meeting, citing “health reasons” for his absence. Later, he sent a note of dissent stating his views. 
    “I believe if the state government decides to do away with the pass-fail system till class VIII, its repercussion will be felt even in higher education. If those students who fare badly in examinations are granted promotions, it will lead to a degeneration of the education system,” Sanyal told TOI on Thursday.

Worst politics played by Mamata Govt. in West Bengal health care

Sudip signals hospital shift

OUR BUREAU 19.11.11

Sudip Bandopadhyay in Siliguri. (Kundan Yolmo) Nov. 18: The state government has decided to shift the proposed super-speciality hospital on the lines of the AIIMS from North Dinajpur’s Raiganj to Kalyani in Nadia. “The state government has now decided that the AIIMS-like hospital will come up in Nadia,” Union junior health minister and Trinamul leader Sudip Bandopadhyay toldThe Telegraph in Calcutta. Earlier in the day, Bandopadhyay who was in Siliguri, said the specialised hospital would come up in a place where it would benefit the maximum number of people. Writers’ Buildings sources said the Centre, which has approved the project and sanctioned Rs 800 crore for it, had to be informed about the change in the hospital site. Congress MP Deepa Das Munshi has already launched an agitation in her constituency Raiganj in support of the hospital there. But sources close to chief minister Mamata Banerjee said Deepa, with whom she does not see eye to eye, would not be given an opportunity to gain popularity in north Bengal. “The AIIMS-like hospital was mooted for Raiganj at the behest of Priya Ranjan Das Munshi, who was then the information and broadcasting minister. Deepa (his wife) is reaping its full political benefit,” a Trinamul leader said. “She knows that if the hospital is set up in Raiganj she will gain a lot of political mileage in north Bengal. It is hardly fair to expect Mamata to allow that especially since Deepa is forever saying nasty things about her.” Deepa today said the decision to deprive north Bengal of a specialised healthcare was a deep-rooted political conspiracy of Trinamul. “North Bengal districts are still a Congress bastion and Trinamul wants to weaken us there by not allowing the hospital to come up in Raiganj,” she said. In August Mamata had said an AIIMS-like hospital would come up in Kalyani in Nadia and that the land for it had been identified. But she had not said anything about shifting it out of Raiganj. Health department officials said more than 100 acres has been identified in Kalyani. “Kalyani, where more land is available, is a much better location than Raiganj,” said a senior official. Writers’ sources said the government would have to inform the Centre if the hospital is shifted. “But that will not come in the way of the project,” said a source. “The location of the facility in the state is not the Centre’s concern.”